A guest post by my colleague Roger Fillion about his summer trip to Italy. Claude S. Weiller
Italian winemaker Gregory Perrucci’s lifted his eyebrows and shook his head. “You added potatoes when you made fava bean purée?” he asked incredulously. “You don’t use potatoes!”
I’d stumbled on an emotional topic for those steeped in the ways of Puglia, the region located in the “heel” of Italy’s boot.
A chef from Puglia had taught me to use potatoes in fava bean purée, a traditional dish from this southern Italian region. The signature dish is made using dried fava beans which are boiled and then either mashed, put through a food mill, or cooked until they dissolve into the consistency of clotted cream. Some cooks add a peeled, sliced potato to the water along with the fava beans. Extra virgin olive oil is added to finish the dish.
“But Mino uses potatoes,” I explained to Gregory, referring to Domenico Maggi, a culinary instructor in the town of Bari. I’d seen Maggi, or “Mino,” prepare a fava bean purée during a cooking demonstration in the Napa Valley. He added potatoes and puréed the whole lot.
Not Gregory.
The conversation turned to fava bean purée while my wife, two children and I were having lunch with Gregory at a fabulous seaside eatery on the picturesque coast of the Ionian Sea. A renown winemaker in nearby Manduria, he helped put Puglia’s primitivo grape on the world wine map. We were his guests at the restaurant and enjoying his wines while sampling raw squid, octopus “meat” balls, fish soup, and more.
When the conversation turned to fava bean purée, Gregory pulled out his cell phone and punched in a number.
“Mino,” he said into the phone. “Are you sitting down? It’s Gregory Perrucci. I understand you use potatoes in your fava bean purée. How can you? You should never use potatoes, only fava beans.”
A friendly argument ensued and Gregory handed me the phone. Mino, whom I’d met in California, said people in parts of northern Puglia do use potatoes. Besides, it was how his mother had made fava bean purée. He said Gregory should stick to what he knows best.
“You make the wine. I make the recipes,” he said, referring to Gregory.
It turns out these two aren’t the only people who have this argument. Mediterranean food expert Nancy Harmon Jenkins notes a recipe in Puglia can change from village to village and household to household.
“While some cooks insist that the only way to make a purée of dried fava beans is with a cooked potato mixed in to give it smoothness, others raise their eyebrows in shocked consternation at the very thought,” she writes in her excellent book, Flavors Of Puglia (Broadway Books, 1997).
So we decided to perform our own test. We made Nancy’s recipe for fava bean purée, which doesn’t include potatoes. We accompanied it with boiled broccoli rabe. The purée, pictured above, was delicious with a unique flavor. The potato version, also excellent, tastes more like the most flavorful mashed potatoes I’d ever eaten.
Which did we prefer? Let’s just say we don’t want to start any new arguments.
Buon appetito,
Roger Fillion
California Olive Ranch